Tubular Skylight vs Traditional Skylight: Which Is Right?

Posted by Solatube on

Tubular Skylight vs Traditional Skylight: Which Is Right?

3 min read

A tubular skylight is a small roof dome and reflective tube that delivers diffused daylight through a ceiling fixture. A traditional skylight is a glazed opening in the roof that gives a view of the sky and can open for ventilation. Choose tubular for a small roof opening and distant rooms, and traditional for views and fresh air.

How they compare

Tubular skylight Traditional skylight
What it is A roof collector, a highly reflective tube, and a diffuser at the ceiling [1]. Glazing set into the roof, usually with a light well down to the ceiling [1].
Roof opening Smaller than most other skylights [2]; much smaller than a conventional skylight [3]. Sized to the glazing. A skylight can admit more than 3 times as much light as a vertical window of the same size [1].
View of the sky None [2]. Yes. Roof windows are simply windows set into the roof [1].
Ventilation None [2]. Operable models can release the hot air that gathers near the ceiling [2].
Heat The small collector minimizes heat loss in winter and heat gain in summer [2]. Can add unwanted heat in summer and lose heat in winter [2]. Roof glazing can receive almost twice the heat of an unprotected west-facing window [1].
Cloudy days Admits considerably less daylight than a large conventional skylight, and works best where clear, sunny days are common [1]. Roof windows and conventional skylights suit places with many cloudy skies [1].
Reaching distant rooms The tube can curve and bend to reach areas far from the building envelope [3]. Relies on a light well or shaft between the roof and the ceiling [1].
Installation A roof opening plus a tube path. The Department of Energy says it is best to have a professional install a skylight [2]. A roof opening plus a shaft. Retrofitting needs a qualified builder or contractor [1].

When a tubular skylight is the better fit

  • The room is far from the roof. The tube can bend to reach areas that windows and conventional skylights cannot [3].
  • You want a small roof opening. Tubular skylights are smaller than most other skylights [2].
  • You want to limit heat gain and loss. Their small collector area helps in both seasons [2].
  • Your climate has many clear, sunny days. That is where tubular skylights work best [1].

When a traditional skylight is the better fit

  • You want a view of the sky. Tubular designs do not provide views [2].
  • You want fresh air. Operable skylights ventilate [2], and the YourHome guide highly recommends openable roof windows in summer, especially in two-story houses [1].
  • Your area is often cloudy. Conventional skylights and roof windows suit those locations [1].

Which Solatube kit if you choose tubular?

If you choose tubular, the Solatube 160 DS is listed for bathrooms, laundry rooms, closets and hallways.

The Solatube 290 DS is listed for kitchens, family rooms, master bathrooms, garages and rooms with high ceilings.

Frequently asked questions

Can a tubular skylight open for ventilation?

No. The Department of Energy says tubular skylight designs do not provide views or ventilation, while operable skylights can open to release hot air [2].

Is a tubular skylight just a smaller skylight?

No. A tubular skylight carries sunlight down a reflective tube to a ceiling diffuser, while a conventional skylight lets light in through glazing set into the roof and usually a light well [1].

Do I need a professional to install either type?

The Department of Energy says it is best to have a professional install a skylight [2]. Solatube’s kits are DIY kits, and Solatube recommends a Premier Dealer for installation.

Not sure which type fits your room?

Send your room and roof details and a Solatube specialist will help you decide, or find a Premier Dealer near you.

References

  1. Australian Government, Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water. “Skylights and roof windows.” YourHome. Accessed October 30, 2026. https://www.yourhome.gov.au/passive-design/skylights
  2. U.S. Department of Energy. “Skylights.” Energy Saver. Accessed October 30, 2026. https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/skylights
  3. Fernandes LL, Regnier CM. “Lighting and visual comfort performance of commercially available tubular daylight devices.” Solar Energy 251:420–437, 2023 (Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory). Accessed October 30, 2026. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0038092X23000282

Related articles